News&insights
[Publication-IPWatchdog] Why High-Quality U.S. Patent Specifications Face Fatal Failures in China
2026-08-28
Patent attorneys Soo-Jin Kim and Ki-Sung Lee of JOOYON KRP IP & Law Firm co-authored an article entitled “Why High-Quality U.S. Patent Specifications Face Fatal Failures in China,” which was published by IPWatchdog, a leading U.S. intellectual property publication, on August 26, 2026.
The article examines why patent specifications that are carefully drafted to meet U.S. standards may nevertheless face unexpected claim narrowing or even invalidation during patent prosecution or invalidation proceedings in China.
Focusing particularly on China’s Support Requirement, the article explains how the Chinese approach fundamentally differs from the U.S. doctrines of Written Description and Enablement, drawing on decisions of the Supreme People’s Court of China and recent patent invalidation cases.
The article highlights that Chinese patent law evaluates an invention not simply from the perspective of whether the inventor possessed the claimed invention at the time of filing, but rather through the concept of a “Technical Solution,” which is defined by the Technical Problem, Technical Means, and Technical Effect, as well as the scope of the invention’s actual technical contribution. As a result, claims that may raise no significant issue under U.S. practice can be rejected in China for lack of support or invalidated after grant.
The article also compares patent practices in the United States, China, Korea, and Japan, and suggests that companies building global patent portfolios should consider the examination and invalidation standards of China and other Asian jurisdictions from the initial drafting stage, rather than simply relying on specifications prepared primarily for U.S. prosecution.
Drawing on its experience and understanding of the differences among U.S., Chinese, and Korean patent practices, JOOYON KRP IP & Law Firm continues to support global companies in developing and protecting their patent portfolios across Asia.
▶ View the original article on IPWatchdog